Rightor Doyle

Nick Nicholby

Andrew Leeds

Leo Cousineau

Elsie Fisher

Katie Harris

Jessy Hodges

Lindsay Mandel

Gary Kraus

Chief Krauss

Charles Parnell

DA Buckner

David Warshofsky

FBI Agent Harris

Cornell Womack

FBI Agent

Patrick Fischler

Lon O'Neil

Ericka Kreutz

Mrs. O'Neil

Anthony Molinari

Shane Taylor

Kirby Howell-Baptiste

Sasha Smith

Reese Levine

Young Barry Berkman

Sarah Burns

Detective Mae Dunn

Romy Rosemont

Claudia Reed

Michael Dempsey

Joe Reed

Andy Carey

Eric

Alejandro Furth

Alejandro Manuel

Michael Villar

Officer Birdwell

London Kim

Assistant Director

Joe Lorenzo

Corrections Officer

Betsy Moore

London Garcia

Owner

John Gloria

John Berkman (voice)

Raul De Anda

Restaurant Musician

Bill Hader

Director

Bill Hader

Writer