Daniel Croix Henderson

Joseph 'Peanuts' Burroughs

Patton Oswalt

Det. Lafayette Baker

Lili Taylor

Mary Todd Lincoln

C.J. Hoff

Louis Weichmann

Larry Pine

Secretary William Henry Seward

Spencer Treat Clark

Lewis Powell

Carlos Luckie Jr.

William Bell

Carrie Lazar

Mrs. Mary Surratt

Tommie Turvey

George Atzerodt

Walker Babington

Spangler

Rebecca Ray

Fanny Seward

Betty Gabriel

Elizabeth 'Lizzie' Keckley

Joshua Mikel

John Surratt Jr.

Antonio J Bell

Milo Simms

John Billingsley

Judge Joseph Holt

Bill Winkler

Jeremiah Dyer

Neal Ghant

Baptist Washington

Craig Nigh

Jefferson Davis

Dan Cordle

Reporter #1

Alphie Hyorth

Chief Judge

Gray Hawks

Defense Attorney Ewing

Van Kelly Clark

Willie Lincoln

Justin Matthew Smith

Willie's Doctor

Jack Lafferty

Reporter #2

Robert C. Treveiler

Lorenzo Thomas

Eric Mendenhall

Oliver Howard

Julius Borden

Newspaper Boy #1

Trace Todd

Newspaper Boy #2

Josh Stewart

Sanford Conover / James Wallace / Charles A. Dunham

Matt Fennell

Co-Producer

Monica Beletsky

Writer

Julie Bush

Consulting Producer

Eva Sørhaug

Director

Robert Humphreys

Director of Photography

Terry Ham

Unit Production Manager

David Berman

Editor