Patton Oswalt

Det. Lafayette Baker

Lili Taylor

Mary Todd Lincoln

Maxwell Korn

Robert Lincoln

Josh Stewart

Sanford Conover / James Wallace

Anthony Marble

George Sanders

Keith Brooks

River Ghost

Julian Green

Sanders' Valet

Nick Westrate

Edwin Booth

Bill Kelly

Jonathan Lamson

Wayne Pére

Judge

Jeffrey Charles Morgan

Dr. Hammond

Sean Ohlman

Confederate Agitator

Brian Troxell

Wake Guest

William J. Simmons

Jesse

Davin Allen Grindstaff

Male Theatre Patron

Andrew Puckett

Sanders' Assistant

Shaun MacLean

Maitre'd

Jena Ziomek

Female Theater Patron

Tim Brittain

Writer

Matt Fennell

Co-Producer

Monica Beletsky

Writer

Julie Bush

Consulting Producer

John Dahl

Director

Jann K. Engel

Art Direction

Trevor Forrest

Director of Photography

Bryan Thomas

Unit Production Manager

Charmaine DeGraté

Consulting Producer

Terry Ham

Unit Production Manager

Damien Smith

Editor