character - Squealer (voice)

character - Self

character - Benji Kaplan

character - Dr. Plowp (voice)

character - Wallace Wells (voice)

character - Gabriel Wolf (voice)

character - Narrator (voice)

character - O.D. (voice)

character - Charley Barnes

character - Matty Banks

character - Roman Roy

character - Ben

character - Norman

character - Brandon McCarthy

character - Peter (voice)

character - Self

character - Self

character - Mr. Becker

character - Self

character - Self

character - Rye Gerhardt

character - Self

character - Self - Guest

character - Self

character - Neil (segment "Veronica")

character - Paul Hirsch

character - Self

character - Wallace Wells

character - Christopher

character - Jimmy Bartlett

character - Self

character - Joe Jonas / Nostradamus' Intern

character - Self (archive footage)

character - Igby

character - Tim Sullivan

character - Andy 'Fish' Troutner

character - Buster

character - Barney O'Grady

character - Lexi at 15

character - Simon Boggs

character - Kevin "Freak" Dillon

character - Biddle Farnsworth

character - Matty Banks

character - Ralph "Ralphie" Parker

character - Jimmy (voice)

character - Mike 'Mookie' Anderson

character - Fuller

character - Self / Presenter

character - Matty Banks

character - Patrick Muldoon Jr.

character - Fuller

character - Self - Cameo (uncredited)

character - Self - Host

character - Self

character - Self - Winner